Disney’s Old Key West Resort Restaurants: A Dining Guide

Olivias Cafe entrance with a sign and lush tropical landscaping.

If you want to be surrounded by Florida nature and charm on your Walt Disney World visit, Disney’s Old Key West Resort is an excellent pick. The pretty pastel buildings and perfect palm trees set the scene for relaxation. This is also one of the quietest resorts from my experience. Old Key West is the original Disney Vacation Club resort. There are framed photos of DVC member families and vacation memories adoringly decorating the walls in the main area of the resort. Disney’s Old Key West Resort has a nice layer of convenience when it comes to amenities. Almost all of the Old Key West resort restaurants are located in one central area near the lobby and pool. The resort has an internal bus system to help guests get around. Let’s take a look at Disney’s Old Key West dining options along with some top menu items to consider.

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Restaurants: Olivia’s Cafe, Gurgling Suitcase and More

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Grab and Go, Quick Service and Mobile Order Restaurants

The Good's Food to Go logo with a rollerskating chef holding a burger in a sketch style.
The sign for Good’s Food to Go. This is a walk up, quick service option at Disney’s Old Key West Resort.

Good’s Food to Go

Good’s Food to Go serves breakfast, lunch, dinner, snacks and desserts in typical American, quick service tastes. This is an outdoor, covered walk up window and a small area with condiments.

For breakfast, expect simple selections like breakfast wraps, a breakfast platter, Mickey waffles, oatmeal and grits with meals around $10.

Lunch and dinner menu items at Good’s Food to Go might include:

1/3 lb Angus Bacon Cheeseburger or Impossible Burger $13.49

Chicken Strips $10.99
Foot-long All-Beef Hot Dog $12.79
Key West Cuban Sandwich $12.79
Turkey BLT Sandwich $12.79
Sunset Vegetable Wrap $10.79
Tuna Salad Sandwich $9.99
Power Salad $13.29
Caesar Salad $11.99

The Sunset Vegetable Wrap at Good’s Food To Go has Black Bean Hummus, Roasted Sweet Potato, Red Peppers, Arugula, and Romaine. This Plant-based options is $10.79.

There is some outdoor seating in this area. It overlooks the boat dock area at Old Key West Resort. It has string lights lit at night.

A white picnic table with blue bench seating, covered by a blue striped umbrella next to the water way at Disney's Old Key West Resort.
Outdoor seating in the pool area at Disney’s Old Key West Resort. This is a convenient area to eat food from Good’s Food To Go.
Housemade Disney chips in a white wrapper on a white picnic table with a veggie wrap in a plastic box behind them.
House made Disney chips in a white wrapper with a veggie wrap behind them. Disney’s house made chips are a favorite among guests.
A self serve soda fountain featuring Coca Cola products at Disney's Old Key West Resort.
A self serve soda fountain featuring Coca Cola products at Disney’s Old Key West Resort. Guests can purchase a special cup that can be used for the duration of their visit. This will work at quick service Old Key West Resort restaurants.

Conch Flats General Store

Conch Flats General Store building in a pastel blue with signage over the window.

To stock the fridge or pick up drinks and snacks, visit Conch Flats General Store.

Each resort has more of a DVC shop like this that sells Disney Vacation Club merchandise and groceries.

This merchandise shop is in the same central location near the resort entrance.

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Lounges

The sign for the Gurgling Suitcase Libations and Spirits on a post.

The Gurgling Suitcase

The Gurgling Suitcase is a small bar with great dining options and some outdoor seating. With entrees you can order from the Olivia’s Cafe menu, The Gurgling Suitcase has some of the best pool side eats you’ll find. Many bars and lounges at Disney World offer similar menu items for adult drinks. You can get favorites here like the Magical Star Cocktail that comes illuminated via glowing ice cube.

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Poolside Dining

At the main pool near the lobby, the options mentioned above are all close by. You can actually access all resort dining options from the main pool except for this next one.

Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks

Turtle Shack Poolside Snacks is located far from the entrance at the pool on the opposite side of the resort. This spot would be good for a quick lunch if you’re staying on this back side of the resort. Expect adult beverages along with typical fast American fare and kids meals.

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Table Service and Signature Dining

Olivia's Cafe is the main and only real non quick service option of the Disney's Old Key West Resort restaurants. Inside it has a coastal, vintage theme with bright walls featuring nautical items like paddles and a lifesaver. A large round table is pictured in a corner next to greenery.
Olivia’s Cafe is the main and only real non quick service option of the Disney’s Old Key West Resort restaurants. Inside it has a coastal, vintage theme with bright walls featuring nautical items like paddles and a lifesaver. Olivia’s Cafe has indoor and outdoor seating.
Olivia's Cafe pineapple coconut bread loaf in a basket.
It’s always nice to have a bread service at a Disney restaurant. The Olivia’s Cafe pineapple coconut bread loaf comes in a basket for the table.

Olivia’s Cafe

Olivia’s Cafe is open for brunch and dinner daily and offers a menu of home style cooking. This is a hidden gem and one the best restaurants at DVC resorts. The Southernmost Buttermilk Chicken here is a fan favorite and something to write home about. It’s probably the best fried chicken around Disney property.

Olivia's Cafe curry pictured with rice, vegetables and sauce.
Olivia’s Cafe West Indian Tofu and Coconut Curry dish. This has Mango-Coconut Curry, Crisp Vegetables, Jasmine Rice, and Cilantro.
Olivia's Cafe seasonal salad pictured with Mixed Greens, Quinoa, Avocado, Edamame, Orange, and Key Lime Vinaigrette.
The Seasonal Market Salad changes throughout the year at Olivia’s Cafe. You may find what is pictured here, Mixed Greens, Quinoa, Avocado, Edamame, Orange, and Key Lime Vinaigrette or something else.

Disney Springs Restaurants are a boat ride away from Disney’s Old Key West Resort.

A boat pulls away from the dock area headed to Disney Springs from Disney's Old Key West Resort.
A boat pulls away from the dock area headed to Disney Springs from Disney’s Old Key West Resort. Disney transportation is complimentary.

Disney water transportation opens even more possibilities. Guests can travel by boat from Old Key West to Disney Springs where you’ll find nearly any kind of food you can imagine. There are many, many restaurants at Disney Springs. Choose from celebrity chef venues like Frontera Cocina or something themed like Rainforest Cafe.

DVC Resale Experts Can Help

DVC Resale Experts is a licensed real estate broker with decades of experience selling Disney Vacation Club. Ready to vacation at Disney year after year? Consider what you can save on deluxe resort hotel stays with a DVC Membership. In addition to Disney’s Old Key West Resort, there are many home resort properties to choose from.

Talk to UsFor more information on Disney Vacation Club, its resorts, and the magical vacations you can have at great value by becoming a member through DVC resale, feel free to talk to any of our friendly professionals with DVC Resale Experts at 844-DVC-FANS (382-3267) or email us at Info@DVCResaleExperts.com.
Disney Blogger Nicole and Disney CEO Bob Iger

Sparkly Nicole

Nicole is a native Floridian who attended the University of Central Florida and decided to call the land of theme parks home. She’s been sharing magical tips, tricks and Orlando travel and tourism favorites online for over a decade.

No Comments

Post A Comment

Related Posts

A three story building with pastel colors at Saratoga Springs Resort at Disney World.
Disney Vacation Club

DVC Welcome Home Weeks 2024

Disney Vacation Club has some exciting extra fun going on for Members this summer. We’re discussing the details of this new perk debuting in 2024 for those who are eligible for Membership Extras. It’s awesome to see Disney introduce new offerings after a handful of

Olivias Cafe entrance with a sign and lush tropical landscaping.
Resort Guides

Disney’s Old Key West Resort Restaurants: A Dining Guide

If you want to be surrounded by Florida nature and charm on your Walt Disney World visit, Disney’s Old Key West Resort is an excellent pick. The pretty pastel buildings and perfect palm trees set the scene for relaxation. This is also one of the

Disney Dreams That Soar is spelled out in the night sky using light up drones in purples and yellows.
Disney Updates

Disney Springs Drone Show: Dreams That Soar FAQs

Disney is a master of storytelling and continues to find exciting new ways to tell those stories. From May 24th through September 2nd, those visiting Disney Springs can enjoy a brand new, colorful Disney drone show in the sky. The Disney Dreams That Soar show